The Archdiocese of the Episcopal Church of Eastern Oregon is closing. Do I hear a collective gasp of horror? Unless you are Episcopalian, particularly from Eastern Oregon, you could probably care less. Why do I bring this up? Because it is an extreme example of clergy acting like kings. I found out about this from Maggie Ross’ blog Voice in the Wilderness. Maggie[1] is an Anglican solitary and author. Here is what she said in her post Transitions.
The Diocese of Eastern Oregon is being dismantled and the parishes set adrift. There seem to be two blatant issues: entitlement and money. The clergy won’t face that their sense of entitlement, their demands for huge compensation packages and their contempt for the laity are a large part of the problem (they seem to think that the reason the church exists is to support them); and the laity are finally being forced to face that the diocesan structure serves only the clergy. Oh yes, and there is the small additional problem that what passes for prayer seems to have become a commodity and many of the clergy don’t seem to know what it might be even if they fell over it.
The formula is medieval: no money, no sacraments. And of course the clergy are too possessive to license people locally without forcing them to be ordained. Isn’t it time we forgot about the structures and just took matters into our own hands?
Far be it from Maggie to pull any punches. I sense a kindred spirit. She brings up a number of issues that are pertinent to the state of the modern Western Church. I’ll use Maggie’s words to highlight the problems which have arisen because of the clergy/laity system, a problem I address in my post Christendom and National Geographic. This may be an exaggerated example, but it does highlight a series of real problems. Most current clergy are good, decent people. But in my opinion, they are participating in a system that can, and often does corrupt them; usually without them even noticing.
Entitlement and Money
In my post The Disease Called Stoicheius Captivitus I discussed the problem of being conformed to the foundational principles of the world. Here are two interrelated examples of the body of Christ acting under the anesthesia of stoicheia, the basic principles of the world. When Christian leaders start feeling that Christians “owe them something” (entitlement), they have clearly stepped away from being servants. Part of the problem is that they have become entangled with money. They are gaining their livelihood from filling a position in a Christian hierarchy. Probably in their “career” they slowly moved from longing to minister, to ministering and being glad they were paid, to being willing to minister but feeling they should be adequately compensated, to feeling they were owed something.
The Structure Serves Only the Clergy
Once you have a two tiered system with those who have control and power and those who don’t; the long term inevitable conclusion can be those with power will use it to benefit themselves, even if it harms others. That’s human nature. One only has to look at the compensation packages of large corporation CEOs, compared to the average wage of the same company, to see this principle in practice. But when the body of Christ starts mimicking corporate structure, abusive corporate behavior will follow. I believe the sin is built into the structure. That’s why Paul warned us so many times to avoid the foundational principles of the world.
Prayer Becomes a Commodity
Once you have paid professionals performing religious duties, ministry can easily become a commodity. Before those reading this, who are not liturgical Christians, give themselves an easy out; can’t this same thing happen with a worship leader? Can’t this same thing happen with the youth pastor? Doesn’t it happen with the mega-church pastor? Let’s be honest, doesn’t it happen with pastors of small churches? Jesus said that godly leadership was like becoming a powerless person; like a young child, like a servant. And we should never say we lead others for their own good (calling themselves benefactors). That is lording over, exactly what Jesus said leaders should never do (Lk. 22:24-27). Yet this is the Western Christian status quo; existing under the ironic title of “servant leadership.”
Forget About the Structures and Take Matters into Our Own Hands
That could appear to be what the modern Western simple church movement is all about. We are angry and tired of the abuse of clergy, so we have taken matters into our own hands. We are commonly accused of being exactly that: cranky usurpers. Do such people exist? Sure, by the boatload. However, that is just reformatting the problem. The real problem is that humans have taken power out of Jesus the Lord’s hands. And the corollary problem is that we are therefore not living in our new covenant relationship with him, where he puts his laws and desires in our hearts and minds, and we obey. We need to work under Jesus lordship to put matters back into his hands.
- How do we in the house/simple/organic church movement avoid taking matters into our own hands?
- Is the problem really with the individual leaders or is the real problem silently built into the system? Can clergy gone wrong actually be victims as well as abusers?
- There are many more problems with the clergy/laity system than Maggie Ross or I have brought up. What percentage of the clergy end up having their soul’s corrupted by it? What about the laity?
- When we step out of the system, how much of it do we end up bringing with us; like bedbugs in our suitcase?
[1] In using her first name, it could appear that I know her. I don’t. But since my first name is Ross I’m doing it to avoid confusion. Maggie Ross is the pen name for Martha Reeves.
















Order Today!